Airsoft Forum banner

Objective Battery Test Titan LION vs. Kypom LIPO vs. HV LIPO - Valken Others

18348 Views 125 Replies 16 Participants Last post by  aotsukisho
aotsukisho

If I sent you some packs, can you do an objective review on them?

Two TITAN LION, one a 2600 and one a 3000.

I want to see if the 3K is the same as the one you got from me earlier and then compare them to a KYPOM 2600/2700mah Brick . Plus I have an old Turnigy Bolt 2S High Voltage and a KYPOM Cylindrical 1500mah pack that I suspect is a LION.

You can keep the packs for your troubles if you do a write up.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
81 - 100 of 126 Posts
Was that a Golden Eagle NIMH? 1200mah?
On another note, do you test NiMh's? I have a random (and old) 8.4 that came with a gun long ago. It never, ever died, I mean you could run that thing for like 5 airsoft events without charging. That battery became a legend to us.

We charged it, but I don't remember it ever slowing down. It probably helped that it was running a tiny stock ak with very little in the way of amp draw.
My battery dyno has the capability of testing any battery type but there is far less detailed information available for non-Li batteries since there are no cell taps. I will have to guesstimate connector resistance in order to provide an overall pack IR measurement, and dissect the pack and attempt to get readings off each individual cell for an individual IR reading. If this wasn't an expensive "race" manually-matched-cell battery to begin with (probably $60-100+ brand new), it's not worth the time.
Was that a Golden Eagle NIMH? 1200mah?
No, it was unbranded. All it says is this:
Cylinder Tints and shades Font Medical equipment Temperature

It also looks like it is covered in duct tape.
See less See more
Only one company I know of Made a 1050/1150 NIMH and that is KAN.

They make good above average output cells.

Got these in a bundle I picked up recently. Never tested the iPower brand before, will be interesting to see how it does even though these were used for an unknown amount of time.

iPower Airsoft Lipo Pack 2s 1100mAh 20C (butterfly)
Capacity - 846mAh, 76.86%
IR - 78.23mΩ, 12C, 13.1A
I'm not sure if my individual example was of below average quality, but this is not good. Worse performance than a Titanpower lol

iPower Airsoft Lipo Pack 2s2p 2200mAh 20C (butterfly)
Capacity - 1562mAh, 70.98%
IR - 26.3mΩ, 13C, 28.6A
Comparable to the Kypom 2s 2200mAh 25C, not bad. Aside from below average claimed-actual capacity%, it is a solid pack.

Do note that the 2200mAh version is a 2s2p configuration so these should be similar readings in terms of calculated C and the IR should scale accordingly. It does not.
See less See more
iPower is an old "Asian" brand. It came out a couple years after iPhone and anything else "i" made a debute.

Here they are one of the others that rebrands the B3

Musical instrument accessory Font Audio equipment Musical instrument Electronic component
See less See more
And from another individual that did some simplistic testing. He works for Federal...
Output device Input device Communication Device Personal computer Office supplies


Kypoms are "average". The 1200 Nano-Techs are Gen 2, perhaps 3 packs. That is notable...
See less See more
Aotsukisho,

Can you post a simple ROF demo of a Titan versus a LIPO...just to show people how slow a Titan is under load?
  • Like
Reactions: 1
I am getting contacted "again" by an old China LIPO maker...wants to sell me new cells for Airsoft...I am checking their specs and nothing is jumping out at me...more to come.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Aotsukisho, are you still around?

The above Chinese Battery company reaching out has some "better" LIPO's she want to send to me for testing.

I asked for a test set of 3.

I would keep one, you would get one and I will ask for a Field Tester for the 3rd...
Aotsukisho,

Can you post a simple ROF demo of a Titan versus a LIPO...just to show people how slow a Titan is under load?
Aotsukisho, are you still around?

The above Chinese Battery company reaching out has some "better" LIPO's she want to send to me for testing.

I asked for a test set of 3.

I would keep one, you would get one and I will ask for a Field Tester for the 3rd...
Hey Guges sorry for the long unexpected hiatus, I am back and will see what I can do regarding the Titan video.

If you'd still like me to test one of those batteries I can do so.
Okay...when they get in...I will send you a few.
Aotsukisho....got some batteries to test!

Wood Cosmetics Fashion accessory Carmine Hardwood


Please confirm where I should send some.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Sorry for the late updates, but initial testing on the August 2022 batch of Guges batteries is complete. I am currently running charge cycling trials but I wanted to get this data out there when I could.


Batteries arrived safe, they are marked only with these stickers. This is really all the information I need


All of them came with miniTam connectors, some of them have foam spacers on them? They will be changed to clone Deans per usual


Connector change complete


These were sent all around 50% charged rather than the industry standard 30%

As of right now, all I have are IR readings taken after charging the battery to 100% for the first time. I assume these lipos are brand new, they certainly look it.

GUGES1 5517178P 3s 1300mAh 20C
0.20 FoM, 10C, 13.0A
111.7mΩ total pack IR
C1: 45.43mΩ (bad cell?)
C2: 29.96mΩ
C3: 28.89mΩ

GUGES2 7520100P 2s 1300mAh 20C
0.27 FoM, 12C, 15.0A
78.8mΩ total pack IR
C1: 34.04mΩ
C2: 34.58mΩ

GUGES3 6018163P 2s 1500mAh 20C
0.37 FoM, 14C, 20.3A
49.8mΩ total pack IR
C1: 20.80mΩ
C2: 21.74mΩ

GUGES7 9020120P 3s 2000mAh 20C
0.26 FoM, 11C, 22.7A
74.6mΩ total pack IR
C1: 22.78mΩ
C2: 22.14mΩ
C3: 23.24mΩ

GUGES10 753496P 2s 2200mAh 20C
0.38 FoM, 14C, 30.0A
33.8mΩ total pack IR
C1: 13.58mΩ
C2: 14.59mΩ

Initial impressions show average cell matching, with the GUGES1 lipo having a very out of balance cell that will hurt performance. This is a smaller sample size but the actual C ratings are a little lower than the Kypom batteries...which is actually a good thing (?) since the Kypoms are rated for 25C instead of 20C.

As mentioned before, charge/discharge trials are still being done to get at least 2 data points per cycle for each battery. Sorry for the wait
See less See more
4
  • Like
Reactions: 3
So, I confronted the new factory about the embellishments of their C rating and they came back with this:

"Regarding the continuous discharging C rate of the airsoft batteries, all the customers just require 10C~15C, but most of them will label it 20C or 25C, if you need the real C rate to be 20C, the MOQ for each item is 2000pcs, more over, the battery materials and manufacturing processes need to be optimized, so the cost will be up over 20%, do you think is it necessary to reach 20C? Actually our current quality can meet the airsoft gun's requirments.

We have been providing to many famous airsoft brands all over the world for many years and receive the good feedeback from them. Such as Zero one airsoft, Colombi Sports, Evolution International S.r.l. and so on. I think our batteries also can meet your requirements.

I am looking forward to hearing from your feedback soon.

Wish you a nice day!"

I am looking for packs that far exceeds AEG requirements. Most of the packs that are listed do that to a minimal degree. But I want better for people so if they "mod" the gun the pack can handle the power needs.

Rather disappointing that they lie or exaggerate to make sales...just like Airsoft Resellers.

It also confirms my suspicion that Airsoft LIPO are 2X rated in their capability for I see a lot of 20/30 C ratings, but under "continuous" use...they seem much slower than what they should be.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 2

Apologies for taking my time with getting these results up, but here's an updated post with some extended testing. Between 10-12 cycles on each battery were done, capacity going in (at 1C) and out (at 2C) has been recorded. IR was recorded after the intial charge to 100%, and all tests were done in a climate controlled room at 65°F with enough time between tests for equipment and batteries to cool down. SD Σ ΔV (self-discharge sum of change in voltage) is the total voltage drop from all cells, measured after 10 days with the batteries fully charged and left in storage.

GUGES1 5517178P 3s 1300mAh 20C
Capacity - 1181mAh, 90.85%
IR - 111.7mΩ, 10C, 13.0A
SD Σ ΔV - 0.04v, 0.95%
Cell 1 was severely mismatched in this battery which likely led to reduced performance especially with constant discharge. A well-matched battery would drop IR to around 90mΩ and raise constant amp rating to 14A or maybe more. Above-average capacity (although still over-rated) for its class.
Verdict: Better QC would mean better performing battery

GUGES2 7520100P 2s 1300mAh 20C
Capacity - 1244mAh, 95.69%
IR - 78.8mΩ, 12C, 15.0A
SD Σ ΔV - 0.01v 0.24%
Capacity is right there but the performance is lacking. Very low self-discharge, though. I thought this would be a 2s version of GUGES1 above but for whatever reason the individual cell IR went up from ~30mΩ to ~34mΩ.
Verdict: Better capacity estimate but mediocre performance

GUGES3 6018163P 2s 1500mAh 20C
Capacity - 1266mAh, 84.40%
IR - 49.8mΩ, 14C, 20.3A
SD Σ ΔV - 0.07v, 1.68%
This one is actually not too bad, even though they severely overestimated capacity by over 18%. Self discharge was high compared to others in this batch, but the rest of the specs were great.
Verdict: Very good battery if you treat it as a 1300mAh model.

GUGES7 9020120P 3s 2000mAh 20C
Capacity - 1956mAh, 97.8%
IR - 74.6mΩ, 11C, 22.7A
SD Σ ΔV - 0.06v, 1.43%
Medium C rating but high capacity means it can dump 20A continuous no problem. The triple butterfly configuration is unusual to me, thicker than a combined stick pack and I guess would fit best in a Crane+buffer tube combo?
Verdict: Dimensionally unwieldy but if it fits it's alright

GUGES10 753496P 2s 2200mAh 20C
Capacity - 2239mAh, 101.77%
IR - 33.8mΩ, 14C, 30.0A
SD Σ ΔV - 0.04v, 0.96%
The winner of this bunch, a rare example of properly stated capacity with not too far off discharge ratings. The brick style bufferfly package unfortunately limits this one to PDW style stocks or PEQ battery boxes but the results of testing shows
Verdict: Solid battery for PDW stock/PEQ box AEGs

The original Kypom test also had a brick type battery win the 'closest specs' award of the group, I wonder if this will turn into a trend or just a coincidence. I go know that minimizing the distance away from the discharge leads is better in terms of reducing localized chemical reactions but I think 2C is low enough where this isn't really a problem.

the battery materials and manufacturing processes need to be optimized, so the cost will be up over 20%
This right here is the important part, and tells the entire story.

I am looking for packs that far exceeds AEG requirements. Most of the packs that are listed do that to a minimal degree. But I want better for people so if they "mod" the gun the pack can handle the power needs.
The experimentation we're doing is a small step in the right direction, knowing true specs will help the customer make informed decisions. I use data from e-cig forums when choosing li-ion cells for WMLs and it is extremely helpful, unfortunately I don't have as good equipment as they do. Being able to graph voltage vs time during discharge will allow quick visual comparison between batteries.

It also confirms my suspicion that Airsoft LIPO are 2X rated in their capability for a see a lot of 20/30 C ratings, but under "continuous" use...they seem much slower than what they should be.
Out of all of the batteries I've tested the overall average 'actual' C rating is 63% of advertised. Those BlueMax li-ion batteries were the bottom two spots, 21.9-25.0% advertised with some of the Kypoms and funnily enough Turnigy's high end Graphene/Bolt LiHV (granted they are rated for a hilariously high 65-75C) from 28.2-37.1%. On the top end for airsoft-size batteries we have some Turnigy Nanotechs and some Kypoms in the >70% range.

Do note that Titanpower li-ions are not part of this percentile list since they do not have C ratings. To refresh everyone's memory I tested the 2600mAh and 3000mAh 2s models and they both came out to 9C...if they were rated by TP at 20C that would mean 45%, 15C would mean 60%, and a market-tailing 10C would still mean 90% advertised continuous discharge.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
63%? We need some standards in this industry so bad...

Imagine if a vehicle advertised 40 miles per gallon but only actually had 25 miles. That maker would not last long.
63%? We need some standards in this industry so bad...

Imagine if a vehicle advertised 40 miles per gallon but only actually had 25 miles. That maker would not last long.
The unfortunate standard is that all current 'hobby' battery products are overstated. It's up to those who actually care to do the legwork and find out what's actually good and not. Like I mentioned above, there is good testing done on li-ion cells like for example Molicel P28A 18650 so we have a ways to go.

TP actually uses quality cells in the batteries I tested, the application is just wrong though and they did blatantly lie about the capacity in their 2380mAh...I mean, 2600mAh model.

Paraphrasing the ancient philosopher Gugistotle III, "buyer beware".

ps. the way the EPA 'tests' MPG is pretty hilarious. Ironically there are gigantic manufacturers who lie about MPG ratings and all that happens is they have to pay fines lol
  • Like
Reactions: 1
63%? We need some standards in this industry so bad...

Imagine if a vehicle advertised 40 miles per gallon but only actually had 25 miles. That maker would not last long.
Here's the odd thing about the mentality in this sport. Rather then admit something is inferior, and that they fell for the marketing "propaganda".

That person who bought the inferior product will defend their position as having the bought the bestest product ever and that the one using science and testing equipment is wrong.
  • Like
Reactions: 3
For those of us going googly eyed reading through this, what are some of the takeaways? What are the least bad batteries?
81 - 100 of 126 Posts
Top